11 Minutes To Eat School Lunch?!?

noquivering25 retweets
11 Minutes To Eat School Lunch?!?

My recent post on the question of food deserts and people's eating habits led me to a topic I haven't touched in a while: school lunches. I wrote about it a lot in 2009-'10, when Congress was working on its once-in-five-years reauthorization of lunch funding.

Amid much hype in late 2010, President Obama signed a reauthorization bill that created new guidelines to encourage more fresh and healthy foods, but allocated an extra 6 cents a day per kid—a miserly sum given that schools have less than $3.00 per day to spend on each kid's lunch, about two-thirds of which goes to overhead, leaving pennies to spend on ingredients.

It's hard for me to imagine that schools can serve up decent food at those rates. And money isn't the only scarce commodity cafeteria operators have to grapple with. Another one is time. Get this :

In the Minneapolis public schools, we are supposed to have 15 minutes to eat, which would be bad enough. But realistically we get only 10 to 11 minutes (we have been timing it).

That's from Minneapolis sixth graders Talia Bradley and Antonia Ritter, writing on the op-ed page of the Minnesota Star Tribune. Ten to 11 minutes to eat lunch? Welcome to fast-food nation, kids, where eating is a necessary inconvenience, to be dispatched with as rapidly as possible.

Nationwide, similar trends hold sway. According to the School Nutrition Association , elementary-school kids get a median of 25 minutes for lunch, while middle and high school students get 30.

Over at the Lunch Tray blog, University of Iowa law professor and parent of public-school children offers the following explanation for what he calls the "incredible shrinking lunch period":

At a meeting with concerned parents, the school superintendent sympathized with our concerns, but explained how much pressure the administrators were under, because of No Child Left Behind, to raise standardized test scores. As a result, administrators felt that they had to add instructional time to the day, and there were only so many places to find those minutes. Hence the disappearing lunch and recess.

What seems to be going on in schools is that administrators are drawing a clean line between eating and education—and squeezing the one in order to make more time for the other in an era of budget cuts.

But as Lunch Tray blogger Bettina Elias Siegel argues, that distinction is false. She points to a post by Karen Le Billion (author of French Kids Eat Everything ), who puts the case like this:

Learning doesn’t stop in the lunchroom, in my opinion. If we are giving our children a short lunch break, we are teaching them that food is an inconvenience, and eating is an interruption in the day. We encourage them to gobble their food, when the research shows that eating more slowly is healthier. In fact, the French spend longer eating, but eat less–in part because that ‘fullness feeling’ (satiety signal) needs about 20 minutes to get from your stomach to your brain. But the French also spend longer eating because they believe that it’s important to teach kids to eat well—it’s a life skill, like reading.

Hustling kids through lunch, by contrast, seems an ideal way to mint life-long customers for the fast-food industry.

Food and Ag Blogger

Tom Philpott is the food and ag blogger for Mother Jones. For more of his stories, click here . To follow him on Twitter, click here . RSS | Twitter

Would you like some cadmium with those fries? A slideshow of recalled fast-food toys.

Get Mother Jones by Email - Free. Like what you're reading? Get the best of MoJo three times a week.

Search this site:

#politics in images

What If The Male Avengers Posed Like The Female One?...

What If The Male Avengers Posed Like The Female One?
What If The Male Avengers Posed Like The Female One?

Picture of daguilar6
7 May 2012

Dave Mather's Twitter Photo

Dave Mather's Twitter Photo
@OwenJones84 @pollytoynbee

Picture of daguilar6
5 Sep 2012

Twitter / ahrcanum: Bo the Obama's dog handler ...

Twitter / ahrcanum: Bo the Obama's dog handler ...
Bo the Obama's dog handler salary 100k, a #Navy Seal 50k. Something is wrong. #politics #sequester

Picture of daguilar6
26 Feb 2013

#politics in videos

Bob Woodward Interview - Part Two | "Larry King Now" ...

Picture of daguilar6
18 Sep 2012
SNEAK PEEK: Larry King @KingsThings continues to talk the price of #politics w/ Bob Woodward -watch pt 2: #LarryKingNow

Trailer Park Boys Countdown to Liquor Day YouTube2

Picture of daguilar6
28 Jul 2012
Politics is like a stupid tax! The stupider you are the more you pay … Humor ...sorta!

The Red Hot Chili Peppers Rock for Barack

Picture of daguilar6
7 Jun 2012
@BarackObama #News: The Red Hot Chili Peppers Rock for Barack #OFA #Obama #politics #p2

#politics in articles

Blind Chinese activist arrives in U.S.

Picture of daguilar6
19 May 2012
China's #humanrights activist Chen arrives in #US #Asia #America #politics #international

House Shoots Down Legislation That Would Have Stopped...

House Shoots Down Legislation That Would Have Stopped Employers From Demanding Your Facebook Password
Sarah currently works as a writer for TechCrunch, after having previously spent over three years at ReadWriteWeb. Prior to becoming a professional blogger, Sarah worked in I.T. across a number of industries, including banking, retail and software. → Learn More Well, that didn’t take long. A proposed Facebook user protection amendment introduced yesterday in the U.S. House of Representatives has already been shot down. The legislation, offered by Democratic Congressman Ed Perlmutter, would have adde...

Picture of daguilar6
29 Mar 2012

Congress to probe security flaws for Libya diplomats...

Picture of daguilar6
7 Oct 2012
There was a day when this would've been called Treason! Security flaws for diplomats #military #war #Libya #politics

#politics in sites

Login | Facebook

Picture of daguilar6
26 Feb 2012
Prayer Warriors for Rick #Santorum @RickSantorum #religion #faith #family #freedom #tcot #teaparty #politics

News Bulletin - 09:35 GMT update

Picture of daguilar6
27 Jan 2012
VIDEO: Actual voicemail from a pro-gun activist received by CSGV. Enjoy! #p2 #politics #Highered #peace

FT - How To Spend It - Home Page

Picture of daguilar6
21 Apr 2012
George Osborne's Dad is sharing how he likes to Spend It: Turnbull & Asser, Mustique, some fancy ham, FT #uk #politics