Lawrence Solomon: Green power failure | FP Comment | Financial Post

runcolman19 retweets
Lawrence Solomon: Green power failure | FP Comment | Financial Post

Lawrence Solomon: Green power failure

Lawrence Solomon   May 11, 2012 – 10:24 PM ET | Last Updated: May 11, 2012 10:59 PM ET


A wind farm in the U.K., which now has 12 million people living in fuel poverty.

Global-warming-related catastrophes are increasingly hitting vulnerable populations around the world, with one species in particular danger: the electricity ratepayer. In Canada, in the U.K., in Spain, in Denmark, in Germany and elsewhere the danger to ratepayers is especially great, but ratepayers in one country — the U.S. — seem to have weathered the worst of the disaster.

America’s secret? Unlike leaders in other countries, which to their countries’ ruin adopted policies as if global warming mattered, U.S. leaders more paid lip service to it. While citizens in other countries are now seeing soaring power rates, American householders can look forward to declining rates.

The North American exemplar of acting on the perceived threat of global warming is Ontario, which dismantled one of the continent’s finest fleets of coal plants in pursuit of becoming a green leader. Then, to induce developers to build uneconomic renewable energy facilities, the Ontario government paid them as much as 80 times the market rate for power. The result is power prices that rose rapidly (about 50% since 2005) and will continue to do so: Ontarians can expect power prices that are 46% higher over the next five years, according to a 2010 Ontario government estimate, and more than 100% higher according to independent estimates. The rest of Canada may not fare much better — the National Energy Board forecasts power prices 42% higher by 2035, while some estimates have Canadian power prices 50% higher by 2020.

The story throughout much of Europe is similar. Denmark, an early adopter of the global-warming mania, now requires its households to pay the developed world’s highest power prices — about 40¢ a kilowatt hour, or three to four times what North Americans pay today. Germany, whose powerhouse economy gave green developers a blank cheque, is a close second, followed by other politically correct nations such as Belgium, the headquarters of the EU, and distressed nations such as Spain.

The result is chaos to the economic well-being of the EU nations. Even in rock-solid Germany, up to 15% of the populace is now believed to be in “fuel poverty” — defined by governments as needing to spend more than 10% of the total household income on electricity and gas. Some 600,000 low-income Germans are now being cut off by their power companies annually, a number expected to increase as a never-ending stream of global-warming projects in the pipeline wallops customers. In the U.K., which has laboured under the most politically correct climate leadership in the world, some 12 million people are already in fuel poverty, 900,000 of them in wind-infested Scotland alone, and the U.K. has now entered a double-dip recession.

The U.S., in contrast, will see power rates decline starting next year, according to the U.S. Energy Information Administration, dropping by more than 22% by the end of the decade and then staying flat to 2035. Why the fall? Mainly because the U.S. will rely overwhelmingly on fossil fuels in the years ahead, not just coal, which dominates the current power system, but increasingly natural gas, which is expected to account for 60% of all new generating capacity in the future. Thanks to fracking, the U.S. effectively has limitless amounts of inexpensive natural gas to add to its limitless coal.

While the rest of the developed world was in thrall to global-warming rhetoric, the U.S. talked the talk but balked at following through. In 1997, then president Bill Clinton and his vice-president, Al Gore, happily signed on to the Kyoto Treaty, which coerced the countries of the developed world into compromising their economies in order to save the planet. While other nations then dutifully complied, the U.S. Senate — as Clinton and Gore knew it would — refused to ratify Kyoto by a 95-0 vote. Clinton’s successor, George W. Bush, did an equally superb job of talking but balking at taking economy-killing measures. Bush successor Barack Obama, although a global-warming true believer, also put global warming on the back burner, preferring to make Obamacare, rather than climate change, his signature issue.

With the Republicans all but certain to control the purse strings following the November elections by dint of a majority in the House of Representatives, European-style legislation in the U.S. in aid of global warming will be impossible, even if the Republicans don’t also capture the Senate and the White House, as polls now indicate they will. In the event of a Republican sweep, the gap between power prices in the U.S. and the rest of the developed world will increase even more as “Drill, baby, drill” Republicans remove the existing restraints on the U.S. fossil-fuel industry, and slash the remaining subsidies on the U.S. renewable-energy industry.

Financial Post

Lawrence Solomon is executive director of Energy Probe .

To see how high power prices are in the EU countries, click here .

Letters to the editor

Do you have an opinion to share with other readers? Then send us a letter .

Please include your address and daytime telephone number. We give preference to letters that refer to a particular article by headline, author and date.

If your letter concerns articles in other sections of the National Post, including business articles that appear in the A section, please send your letter here .

Copyright in letters and other materials sent to the publisher and accepted for publication remains with the author, but the publisher and its licensees may freely reproduce them in print, electronic and other forms.

Junk Science Week

FP Comment’s annual Junk Science Week celebrates the scientists, NGOs, activists, politicians, journalists, media outlets, cranks and quacks who toil to advance the principles of junk science. Junk Science occurs when science is politicized and facts and risks are exaggerated, distorted and misrepresented.

Junk Science Week is over for 2011, but its exposés remain relevant.

No Pigou Club

The NoPigou Club aims to counter the ideas of the Pigou Club, an informal assembly of economists and pundits who support the idea of raising gasoline taxes. Arthur C. Pigou was an early 20th-century British economist, one of the fathers of welfare economics. We view the Pigou approach as just another form of central planning dressed up in free market terminology.

Our Partners

#climate in images

Cover of Bloomberg Business Week nails it: "It's Glob...

Cover of Bloomberg Business Week nails it:
Cover of Bloomberg Business Week nails it: "It's Global Warming, Stupid" #frankenstorm #climate

Picture of daguilar6
1 Nov 2012

Environmental Action's Twitter Photo

Picture of daguilar6
5 May 2012
Seen this? #climate denial think tank equates #science with mass murder. via @EnviroAction more

Arlo Hemphill's Twitter Photo

Arlo Hemphill's Twitter Photo
Picture: #OceanCity #Maryland Boardwalk under #Sandy #frankenstorm #hurricane #climate

Picture of daguilar6
29 Oct 2012

#climate in videos

Superstorm Sandy: Climate Comes Home

Picture of daguilar6
2 Dec 2012
VIDEO: What a roller coaster looks like after #climate change. #Sandy

Sea levels in Norway

Picture of daguilar6
1 Jun 2012
See how sea level rise "competes" with land uplift in Norway #climate #ClimateChange #Science #klima

Wilton Park Dialogues

Picture of daguilar6
23 Mar 2012
Video - #Security and #defence experts discuss the impact of #climatechange with @wiltonpark #climate

#climate in articles

Nasa scientist: climate change is a moral issue on a ...

Picture of daguilar6
13 Apr 2012
Nasa scientist: #climate #change is a moral issue on a par with #slavery?

Nasa scientist: climate change is a moral issue on a ...

Picture of daguilar6
7 Apr 2012
Nasa scientist Jim Hansen: climate change "a moral issue on a par with slavery" @guardian @EdSciFest #climate

After Greenpeace Protests, Apple Promises to Dump Coa...

After Greenpeace Protests, Apple Promises to Dump Coal Power
Apple is cleaning up its energy act. The computer company says that by early next year, the energy used to power its worldwide data centers will all come from renewable sources, such as solar, wind power, or hydro-electric dams. It announced the news Thursday in a post to its website. That’s a victory for the environmental activists at Greenpeace, who have been pressuring Apple for more than a year to clean up its act and commit to renewable energy. A major sticking point has been Apple’s Maiden, N...

Picture of daguilar6
18 May 2012

#climate in sites

Login | Facebook

Picture of daguilar6
8 May 2012
What are the perceptions of #climate change? How do they impact communication & behavioral change? #C4Climate

Welcome to Facebook - Log In, Sign Up or Learn More...

Picture of daguilar6
5 Oct 2011
Join the conversation: Oxfam's #GROW campaign to fix the food system #women #climate #ag #globaldev

News Bulletin - 09:35 GMT update

Picture of daguilar6
21 Jan 2012
This must-watch, shocking animation from @NASA shows our warming world in 30 seconds. Via @ConservationOrg #climate