Dianeravitch

How Should Art Be Assessed?


twoducks4 retweets

June 17, 2012 //

In defense of multiple-choice testing of the arts, she writes:

The point of arts education shouldn’t be to teach children to simply “enjoy art”–we are, after all free to choose which art we enjoy, or whether we enjoy it at all. Rather, it should be to give children the skills and background knowledge to experience art or music in an informed and more than superficial sense–much of which is about understanding and identifying concepts, vocabulary, and techniques in ways that can be assessed through multiple choice assessments. A major reason that high-quality education needs to include the arts is certain arts-related information–such as names and work of key artists and composers, specific musical or artistic vocabulary and meanings, and artistic movements over time and their relationship to broader historical and social trends–is key cultural knowledge that our students need to be culturally literate. But arts and music instruction in our schools has often ignored cultural literacy and key concepts in favor of performance and “creativity.” 

I don’t agree.

I understand and embrace the idea of cultural literacy, but I don’t think that multiple-choice standardized tests are the best way to teach it or to assess it. If a teacher of music wants students to understand the differences between Mozart and Schoenberg, the best way to do that is to listen to their music and discuss the differences. If the teacher of the arts wants students to understand the differences between classical Greek and Roman architecture, the best way to do it is to view it and discuss it. Picking a bubble is no substitute nor is it a valuable way to learn about art.

It is easy to memorize the names and work of key artists and composers to prepare for a test, and just as easy to forget them when the test is over.

If we want our students to have important cultural knowledge as part of their cultural literacy, we should expose them to the experience that this knowledge represents. We should encourage them to see, feel, hear, and engage with the art or music of other times and places. To the extent that they experience arts as a part of life–their own as well as its creator–they will remember it and have it as part of their own experience.

There is something in a bubble test that is inherently at odds with the arts. One can indeed test for superficial recall, not only in the arts but in other subjects as well. And there are times when it is useful to know the results of large-scale assessment. NAEP is valuable, for example, in providing a snapshot of the state of reading, math, science, history and other subjects. But it is only a snapshot. And the results that are informative for a nation, a state, or a district are less informative and less valid for individual students. For the purposes of large-scale assessment, multiple-choice standardized testing is useful and cheap.

But if it is understanding and discernment that we value, there is not a good case to be made for multiple-choice standardized testing. If it is learning that we care about, there is not a good case to be made for multiple-choice, standardized testing. If it is individual children that we care about, then we want to know what they have learned and what they understand. Conceptual knowledge does not lend itself to bubble tests.

Diane

Michele

says:

Enter your comment here...

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

Email (required) (Address never made public)

Name (required)

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. (  Log Out  /  Change  )

You are commenting using your Twitter account. (  Log Out  /  Change  )

You are commenting using your Facebook account. (  Log Out  /  Change  )

Blog Topics

Search for:

Previous posts

Follow blog via email

Enter your email address to follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 654 other followers

Email check failed, please try again

Sorry, your blog cannot share posts by email.

#arts in images

meditating with my new work - Buddha

http://twitpic.com/3nz5hp

meditating with my new work - Buddha
meditating with my new work - Buddha

Picture of daguilar6
8 Jan 2011
6K retweets

ONESONG's Photo | Lockerz

http://lockerz.com/s/200039570

ONESONG's Photo | Lockerz
Lockerz: A Social Life That Pays. Earn points (PTZ) just for sharing images and videos! Use PTZ to get the best prices on top fashion and electronics brands.

Picture of daguilar6
10 Apr 2012
1K retweets

AMN GLOBAL 's Photo: | Lockerz

Picture of daguilar6
19 Jan 2011
968 retweets
UASAP one of the worlds major ARTISTS spotlights will be held in Baltimore August 5th 2012. #arts

#arts in videos

Epic School Battle

Picture of daguilar6
6 May 2012
1K retweets
Excellent PSA by @adoptthearts on the importance of the #arts in public schools. A must watch! #ufglobal #artsed

Films By Peter Dukes and Dream seekers productions

Picture of daguilar6
2 Jun 2012
5K retweets
Please check out the excellent #Films By Peter Dukes and Dream seekers productions #dreamseekerfans #Arts and #film

Old Man In Nursing Home Reacts To Hearing Music From ...

Picture of daguilar6
11 Apr 2012
5K retweets
an unbelievable and moving use of music :: WOW :: Old Man In Nursing Home Reacts To Hearing Music From His Era #arts

#arts in articles

OBWD Magazine

Picture of daguilar6
12 Jan 2012
94 retweets
Check out the new look blog @ new posts, experiences, things we're liking #fashion #culture #arts #design

Café McMullen: Arts Education: Why Is It Important?...

Picture of daguilar6
14 Apr 2012
35 retweets
Arts #Education: Why Is It Important? - Huffington Post - RT @ContempArtNews <<= @FranziskaSP @maurielena

ArtSpotter Aims To Become Largest Arts Venue Database...

http://readwriteweb.com/archives/...

ArtSpotter Aims To Become Largest Arts Venue Database In The World
Picture this: You're in a new city and forgot to research its art scene before arriving. Does your iPhone have a solution to this first world problem ? Thanks to the new app, ArtSpotter , it just might. ArtSpotter was created by UK-based Raphaëlle Heaf, who has worked in the contemporary art world for more than 10 years.

Picture of daguilar6
10 Dec 2011
31 retweets

#arts in sites

YouTube - Broadcast Yourself.

http://youtube.com/das_captcha?ne...

Vorgeschlagene Sprache (von uns festgelegt): Deutsch Vorgeschlagene Standorteinstellung (von uns festgelegt): Deutschland Durch den Standortfilter werden in Listen wie Meistgesehen und in den Suchergebnissen Videos aus diesem Land bzw. dieser Region angezeigt. Du kannst die einzelnen Einstellungen über die Links unten in der Fußzeile ändern. Klicke auf "OK", um die Einstellung zu übernehmen, oder auf "Abbrechen", um "English (US)" als Sprache und "Weltweit (alle)" als Standortfilter festzulegen. Ab...

Picture of daguilar6
19 Jun 2012
1K retweets

MiamiHerald.com - Miami & Ft. Lauderdale News, Weathe...

http://MiamiHerald.com/

MiamiHerald.com - Miami & Ft. Lauderdale News, Weather, Miami Dolphins & More
The state would allow three casino resorts on the condition they inject at least $6 billion into the local economy, according to identical bills being proposed in the House and Senate. E-mails from Gov. Rick Scott’s Blackberry are part of a host data that has been lost from his transition into the governor’s office.

Picture of daguilar6
10 Mar 2013
3K retweets

YouTube - Broadcast Yourself.

Picture of daguilar6
30 Jan 2012
3K retweets
Jan25: KFC Wall art exhibit in Tahrir: via @youtube #Arts #Tahrir #Egypt #Cairo